You've been with the same bank for 10 or perhaps 20 years. You've made your mortgage repayments on time, you've been a loyal customer, and you'd like to think the bank is looking after you.
Then you see another bank advertising a lower mortgage interest rate, or offering several thousand dollars in cashback to new customers.
It's natural to wonder:
Why isn't my bank offering me the same deal?
That's a conversation I regularly have with homeowners.
In my experience, banks don't necessarily reward long-standing customers with their most competitive mortgage offers.
But that doesn't mean switching banks is automatically the right decision.
I've worked in financial services for more than 20 years, including nine years assessing home loan applications for a major New Zealand bank.
When clients ask me about refinancing, the biggest motivation is almost always the possibility of a lower interest rate. Cashback incentives also attract attention. Occasionally, clients want mortgage features such as an offset account or a revolving credit facility that their existing bank doesn't provide.
But my approach is straightforward.
I don't recommend refinancing simply because another bank advertises a lower interest rate or offers cashback. I want to establish whether switching will genuinely leave my clients financially better off.
And sometimes, after doing the calculations, my recommendation is to stay exactly where they are.
Let me explain why.
The short answer: Refinancing is only worth it if the benefits outweigh the costs of switching and the new bank approves your loan. Sometimes the best advice is to stay where you are.
Is It Worth Refinancing Your Mortgage in New Zealand?
Refinancing your mortgage can be worthwhile if the financial benefits of switching to another lender exceed the costs, and the new mortgage structure better suits your needs.
Potential benefits include lower interest rates, a cashback incentive or access to features such as an offset mortgage.
However, you also need to account for legal fees, valuation costs, possible fixed-rate break fees and any cashback that must be repaid to your existing lender.
Most importantly, the new bank must be prepared to approve your mortgage.
This is why I believe homeowners should compare their entire mortgage position rather than simply comparing advertised rates.
What Is the Difference Between Refixing and Refinancing?
These two terms are often confused.
Refixing means agreeing to a new fixed interest rate, generally with your existing bank, when your current fixed-rate term expires or otherwise as permitted under your loan agreement.
Refinancing generally means replacing your existing home loan with a new loan, often by moving your mortgage to a different bank.
Refixing is usually simpler because you remain with your existing lender. Refinancing involves a new application, the new lender's approval process and potentially additional costs.
However, refinancing can sometimes provide benefits that aren't available through your existing bank.
The important question isn't whether one option is inherently better than the other. It's which option produces the better overall financial outcome for your circumstances.
1. Don't Compare Interest Rates Without Looking at the Full Cost
Imagine you're paying 5.75% on your existing mortgage, and another bank is advertising 5.50%.
That lower interest rate looks attractive.
But how much would you actually save?
Here's a simple hypothetical example, not a client case. On a $500,000 mortgage, a 0.25% lower rate is roughly $1,250 a year in interest, assuming interest-only repayments. That's before legal fees, valuation costs, fixed-rate break fees and any cashback you may have to repay.
And what would it cost to move?
When I assess refinancing for clients, I look at two separate components.
The upfront financial benefit
I start with any cashback incentive offered by the new bank.
From that amount, I deduct the costs associated with switching, which may include:
Solicitor or conveyancing fees.
Registered valuation costs, if required.
Fixed-rate break fees, if applicable.
Repayment of a previous cashback contribution.
Other lender or settlement fees.
A "registered valuation" is a formal valuation of your home by a registered valuer. The new bank uses it to decide how much it's prepared to lend against your property.
This gives us an indication of the net upfront benefit or cost.
The ongoing interest cost
I then compare the interest that clients are likely to pay under the proposed mortgage structure with the new bank against what they would pay by remaining with their existing lender.
This comparison needs to account for the mortgage balances, fixed-rate terms, repayment arrangements and the period over which the two options are being compared.
I don't believe a lower advertised rate tells the whole story.
What matters is the overall financial benefit after considering the upfront costs, ongoing interest and the structure of the mortgage.
Sometimes a refinance looks attractive until all these costs are included.
And I've encountered exactly that situation.
2. Real Client Example: Why I Recommended Staying With the Existing Bank
In November 2026, I reviewed a refinancing opportunity for clients with an outstanding mortgage of about $790,000 .
They were considering moving from their existing lender, which I'll call Bank A, to another bank offering a $5,000 cashback incentive.
At first glance, $5,000 sounds like a compelling reason to switch.
But I wanted to understand the full financial picture before making a recommendation.
The proposed mortgage structure involved fixing half the borrowing for one year and half for two years.
The rates we compared were:
6 months: Bank A (existing) 5.39%, potential new bank 5.64%
1 year: Bank A (existing) 5.59%, potential new bank 5.74%
18 months: Bank A (existing) 5.89%, potential new bank 5.94%
2 years: Bank A (existing) 5.95%, potential new bank 6.14%
Rates are from the client's historical comparison, not current advertised mortgage rates.
You'll notice something important.
Bank A was offering lower rates across all four fixed-rate terms in this comparison.
The main attraction of the other lender was its cashback offer.
What was the cashback actually worth?
New bank cashback: $5,000
Estimated registered valuation: −$1,000
Estimated legal fees: −$1,500
Net upfront cashback benefit: $2,500
The $5,000 incentive was therefore worth an estimated $2,500 after these two switching costs.
In this case, the clients' fixed terms were expiring, so no fixed-rate break fee applied. Their cashback period with Bank A had also expired, so there was no cashback to repay. That's why neither cost is part of the calculation. For many homeowners, one or both would be.
What about the interest?
To compare the two options on the same basis, I assumed interest-only repayments and that the one-year portion would refix at the same rate for the second year.
Over two years, that gave total interest of about $91,500 with Bank A and about $94,200 with the new bank, roughly $2,700 more.
The cashback was worth about $2,500 after the valuation and legal costs, so the clients would have been slightly worse off, by about $200, before any other switching costs, even if the valuation went smoothly. Future rates would of course have differed, so this is a comparison, not a forecast.
But there was another concern that I considered particularly important.
What if the property valuation didn't support the refinance?
The proposed new bank required a registered valuation, estimated to cost $1,000.
That created a risk for the clients.
They could pay for the valuation only to discover that the property's value was insufficient to satisfy the new bank's lending criteria. In that situation, they might incur the valuation cost without being able to proceed with the refinance.
Even if the valuation was acceptable, the overall financial benefit from switching was marginal at best.
I therefore recommended that the clients remain with Bank A.
The lesson: A $5,000 cashback offer doesn't automatically mean you'll be $5,000 better off.
And when the potential financial benefit is small, you also need to think carefully about the risks of incurring costs before the refinance has been approved.
This is the kind of comparison I believe homeowners should receive before making a decision.
3. Before Switching Banks, Ask Your Existing Bank for a Better Deal
This is one of the first things I do when reviewing refinancing options for existing clients.
I investigate whether their current bank is prepared to offer a more competitive interest rate or a retention cashback incentive.
A retention cashback is an incentive a lender may offer to encourage an existing mortgage customer to remain with the bank.
This can be attractive because the client may receive a financial benefit without incurring the full costs of moving to another lender.
How much retention cashback can you get?
In my experience, as at November 2026, where the loan-to-value ratio is below 80%, retention cashback offers can be around 0.3% of the outstanding mortgage balance .
For example:
$400,000 mortgage: about $1,200
$600,000 mortgage: about $1,800
$800,000 mortgage: about $2,400
These are examples based on what I've encountered in practice, not guaranteed offers or universal bank policies.
The bank has complete discretion over whether to offer a retention incentive.
I've also found that banks are generally more reluctant to offer retention cashback where the loan-to-value ratio is above 80%.
But the important point is that it's worth investigating.
Why I compare offers before recommending a switch
If another lender offers an attractive mortgage package, we can approach the client's current bank and see whether it's prepared to respond with competitive terms.
Sometimes that might involve a better interest rate. Sometimes it might involve a retention cashback. And sometimes the existing bank won't improve its offer.
Either way, the client can make a decision based on the available options.
If your own rate has changed recently and you weren't sure why, my article Why Your Mortgage Rate Just Changed (And Nobody Told You Why) is worth a read before you compare offers.
My objective is not to move a client's mortgage unnecessarily. It's to help them obtain the best overall financial outcome available for their circumstances.
4. When Is the Best Time to Refinance Your Mortgage?
You can review your mortgage structure at any time.
However, I've found that approximately 60 days before a fixed-rate term expires is an ideal time to investigate refinancing.
This is generally around the time the existing bank starts communicating with the client about their upcoming rate renewal.
It gives us an opportunity to review the mortgage, compare available options and decide whether staying or switching makes sense.
This is based on my experience, not a rule set by the banks. Timing can vary, so check when your own fixed-rate term ends.
There is also an important financial reason for this timing.
Avoiding unnecessary fixed-rate break fees
When you refinance during an existing fixed-rate term, your bank may charge a fixed-rate break fee. The amount depends on the prevailing wholesale interest rates, your outstanding home loan amount and how long is left on the fixed-rate period.
That fee can make switching unattractive, even if another bank is offering a lower interest rate, so I establish the actual figure before recommending a move.
However, when the fixed-rate term expires and the loan rolls onto a floating rate, you can generally repay or refinance that portion without an early fixed-rate break fee.
For a broader look at fixed and floating rates, see my article on fixed vs floating mortgages in NZ .
That's why, if refinancing makes sense, I often recommend arranging settlement with the new bank for shortly after the existing fixed-rate term expires. This allows us to coordinate the switch while avoiding unnecessary break fees.
Of course, we also want to minimise the time the client spends paying a potentially higher floating interest rate.
If a mortgage is split into several fixed-rate portions with different expiry dates, the timing requires additional planning.
The main point is that when you refinance can be almost as important as where you refinance.
For independent guidance on refinancing and potential costs, you can also read Sorted's guide to refinancing your mortgage .
5. Don't Forget About Cashback You May Have to Repay
Cashback incentives can make a mortgage offer attractive.
But they commonly come with conditions.
In my experience, banks often require clients to retain their mortgage for approximately three or four years to avoid having to repay some or all of the cashback.
If the client switches before the agreed period has ended, the bank may require repayment of part of the original incentive. That amount is often calculated on a pro-rata basis, although the actual agreement determines what is payable.
For me, this is simply another part of the refinancing calculation. I establish how much the client would be required to repay and include it in the overall comparison.
For example, a new bank might offer $5,000 cashback, but if the client must repay $2,000 to the existing bank, that reduces the financial benefit considerably.
Then we still need to consider legal fees, valuation costs and any other switching expenses.
I don't want clients making decisions based on the size of a new cashback offer without understanding what they'll actually receive after costs.
Always check your original cashback agreement before deciding to refinance.
6. Sometimes Refinancing Is About Mortgage Structure, Not Interest Rates
Although lower interest rates are the biggest reason clients approach me about refinancing, the structure of the mortgage can sometimes be just as important.
I've encountered clients who have substantial savings sitting in a bank account while paying mortgage interest on their home loan. They may be earning some interest on their savings, but the interest they're paying on their mortgage can be considerably higher, particularly after considering tax on savings interest.
In those circumstances, an offset mortgage may be worth investigating.
How an offset mortgage can help
Suppose a homeowner has:
A $500,000 mortgage.
$50,000 in savings.
With an appropriate offset facility, those savings could offset $50,000 of the eligible mortgage balance. The client would then pay interest on $450,000 rather than the full $500,000, assuming the savings remained constant and the full offset applied.
The savings remain accessible, which can be valuable for emergencies or planned expenses.
But not every bank offers offset mortgages. So if a client's existing lender doesn't offer a suitable offset facility, refinancing to a lender that does may be worth considering.
However, there's an important qualification. The interest rate on an offset mortgage portion may differ from a standard fixed mortgage rate. Therefore, I'd compare the total interest benefit with the alternative structure before recommending a switch.
What about revolving credit?
A revolving credit mortgage works differently. It generally allows clients to use a flexible credit facility where the interest charged depends on the outstanding daily balance.
This can suit borrowers who manage their cash flow carefully and regularly reduce the balance.
However, it isn't appropriate for everybody. If a client is likely to redraw funds frequently and never reduce the debt, the facility might not deliver the expected benefit.
I wouldn't recommend an offset or revolving credit facility simply because a client has heard about one from a friend.
I want to understand how they manage their money and whether the structure will genuinely work for them.
For more on structuring a home loan to reduce interest, see my article How To Structure Your First Home Loan So You Don't Waste Thousands On Interest . It was written for first-home buyers, but the mortgage-structure ideas also apply to existing homeowners.
7. Just Because You Have a Mortgage Doesn't Mean Another Bank Will Approve You
This is an important consideration that homeowners sometimes overlook.
When you refinance to another bank, you're effectively applying for a new mortgage .
That new lender must assess your application under its current lending criteria. And your financial position may have changed considerably since your original mortgage was approved.
For example, you may have:
Changed jobs or started self-employment.
Experienced a reduction in household income.
Taken on additional personal debt.
Developed adverse credit history.
Had problems with bank account conduct.
A property value, or a loan-to-value ratio, that doesn't meet the new bank's lending criteria.
"Account conduct" is how you've managed your everyday bank accounts, for example whether you've gone overdrawn or had payments declined. A new bank will look at your recent statements when you apply.
Even if you've been making your mortgage repayments to your existing bank, the new lender may not be satisfied that you meet its credit and affordability requirements.
Different banks can also assess the same financial circumstances differently.
Your property's value matters too. Your loan-to-value ratio (LVR) is simply the size of your loan compared with the value of your home. In my experience, it's a common reason a new bank declines or limits a refinance. If the valuation comes in lower than expected, the new bank may decline the application or limit what it's prepared to lend. That's why I consider whether the valuation is likely to support the refinance before clients pay for one.
I've encountered situations where a client's circumstances simply weren't suitable for the new bank's credit policies. In those cases, staying with the existing bank may be the appropriate recommendation.
This is another reason I assess the client's overall financial position before suggesting a refinance.
I don't want clients spending money on legal work or property valuations before we've properly considered whether the new lender is likely to approve the application.
8. Don't Extend Your Mortgage Back to 30 Years Just to Reduce Repayments
This is something I'm particularly cautious about.
Imagine a client has 20 years remaining on their existing home loan. They decide to refinance, and the proposed mortgage is structured over a new 30-year term.
Their monthly repayments may fall. At first glance, that can seem attractive.
But the problem is that the client is now potentially paying interest for another ten years. That could increase the total cost of the mortgage substantially.
I generally wouldn't recommend extending the mortgage term simply to make the monthly repayments look more affordable. The new lender would need a sound reason for doing so, and I'd need to be satisfied that it suited the client's circumstances and financial goals.
There may be situations where a longer term is justified, particularly when managing genuine cash-flow pressures. But it needs to be a deliberate decision with the long-term financial consequences clearly explained.
Reducing your monthly repayment isn't necessarily the same as reducing the cost of your mortgage.
When I compare refinancing options, I generally want to preserve the client's remaining mortgage term rather than automatically reset it to 30 years.
The goal is to make wise financial decisions, not simply produce the lowest possible repayment today.
9. How I Decide Whether to Recommend Refinancing
When I review a client's mortgage, I work through these questions:
What does the client want to achieve? Lower interest costs, better cash flow, an offset facility or a cashback offer.
What will it cost to switch? Legal fees, valuation costs, break fees and any cashback that must be repaid.
What are the alternative interest rates and mortgage structures? I compare the expected interest costs on a consistent basis.
Can the existing bank provide a better offer? A better rate or a retention cashback.
Will the new bank approve the application? Income, debts, account conduct (how you've managed your everyday accounts), property valuation, credit history and other factors relevant to the new lender's assessment.
What is the net financial benefit to the client?
If refinancing leaves the client materially better off and the lending is suitable, I'll recommend considering the move. If the numbers don't support it, I'll explain why staying may be the better option.
That's the approach I took in the about $790,000 example earlier in this article.
Frequently Asked Questions About Refinancing in NZ
Is it worth refinancing my mortgage for a lower interest rate?
It depends. A lower rate only helps if the saving is bigger than the cost of switching, including legal fees, valuation costs, fixed-rate break fees and any cashback you have to repay. In my experience, a lower advertised rate alone doesn't tell the whole story.
How much does it cost to refinance a mortgage in New Zealand?
It varies by lender and circumstances. The costs may include solicitor fees, registered valuation fees, discharge or administration charges, fixed-rate break fees and repayment of an existing cashback. In one recent case, I estimated about $1,000 for a registered valuation and about $1,500 in legal fees. Your costs may be different, so always get the actual figures before you decide.
Can I get cashback when refinancing my mortgage?
Possibly. Some banks offer cashback to eligible customers who refinance, but offers, eligibility criteria and repayment conditions vary. In my experience, banks often require you to keep the mortgage for about three or four years to avoid repaying some or all of the cashback, so read the conditions before you decide.
Can I get cashback from my existing bank without refinancing?
Sometimes. In my experience, as at November 2026, existing lenders may offer retention cashback, particularly where the loan-to-value ratio is below 80%. These offers are entirely at the bank's discretion.
Can I refinance before my fixed mortgage rate expires?
Yes, but your bank may charge a fixed-rate break fee. It depends on prevailing wholesale rates, your outstanding loan amount and how long is left on the fixed term, so get the actual figure from your bank before you decide.
How long before my fixed rate expires should I review my mortgage?
I generally recommend starting about 60 days before your fixed rate expires. That's based on my experience, not a bank rule, and it usually gives enough time to compare lenders, negotiate offers and plan any refinance settlement.
Do I need a property valuation to refinance?
Not necessarily. It depends on the new lender, the property, the loan-to-value ratio and the lender's valuation criteria. If a registered valuation is required, you may have to pay for it upfront, even if the refinance doesn't go ahead.
Can I refinance if my financial circumstances have changed?
Possibly, but the new lender will assess your application under its current lending criteria, so changes in income, employment, debts, account conduct or credit history may affect whether it approves you. That's why I review your overall financial position before suggesting a refinance.
Should I refinance or simply refix with my existing bank?
It depends on the overall financial benefit, your current mortgage terms, the offers available and your circumstances. Sometimes refixing with your existing bank is the better choice, particularly when switching costs outweigh the benefits. In one recent case, I recommended the clients stay with their existing bank.
My Final Advice: Don't Assume Bank Loyalty Gets You the Best Mortgage Deal
If there's one thing I'd encourage every New Zealand homeowner to do, it's this:
Don't assume that because you've been with the same bank for years, you're automatically receiving the best mortgage deal available.
It costs nothing to start a conversation about your options.
Another bank might offer a lower interest rate, an attractive cashback or a mortgage structure that could save you interest over time.
But before switching, I'd also give your current bank an opportunity to improve its offer.
Sometimes they'll respond with a better interest rate. Sometimes they'll offer a retention cashback. And sometimes another bank will provide a better overall outcome.
The important thing is to base the decision on the numbers, not simply on loyalty, frustration or an attractive advertisement.
Ideally, have that conversation around 60 days before your fixed-rate mortgage expires. But remember, your mortgage can be reviewed at any time.
You don't necessarily need to switch banks to improve your mortgage. You need to establish whether there's a better financial outcome available.
That's what a proper mortgage review should help you determine.
How I'm paid
I'm usually paid commission by the lender if a refinance goes ahead, and I don't charge my clients a fee. If you stay with your current bank, I'm not paid for that work, but I'd still recommend staying when that's the better option for you.
Is Your Current Bank Giving You the Best Mortgage Deal?
If your fixed-rate mortgage is approaching expiry, or you're wondering whether refinancing could save you money, I'd be happy to review your options.
We'll compare your existing mortgage with potential alternatives, consider the costs of switching and investigate whether your current bank may be prepared to offer better terms.
If refinancing makes financial sense, I'll explain why. And if staying with your existing bank is the better decision, I'll tell you that too.
Andre Botha is a Mortgage Adviser with Lookahead, trading under ASA Investments Limited. This article is general information and does not constitute personalised financial advice. Mortgage rates, lender criteria, cashback offers and fees can change. Actual savings depend on individual circumstances and must be assessed before making a decision. Read our Disclosure Statement .